Analysing Park 51 After 9 11 Religion Essay

Park 51 is an Islamic community centre located two blocks from land zero in lower Manhattan.This undertaking has lightened the fire towards Islam and Muslims in New York metropolis and beyond. The choler towards Muslims has spread to many parts of the state, there are many bias onslaughts towards Muslims occur in New York city.Many Americans opposed the building of this community centre because it is near the site where 9/11 onslaughts occur. They thought that the onslaught on universe trade centre was made in the name of Islam. While on the other manus adult male Feisal abdul rauf the 1 who is responsible for this centre said that this centre will play an of import function in advancing peace and multi interfaith duologue non merely in America but all over the universe. Many Americans believe it will be a mosque, in fact it is a edifice consist of 15 floors and the mosque will busy merely the top two floors. This community centre has been a controversy issue. It has been received by many resistance every bit good as support. Some believe that park 51 is a mosque nevertheless others argue that it is an Islamic community centre and merely top floors are a mosque.

Many Americans support the building of the undertaking including 9/11 households of the victims. They said it would be honored for their victims to construct that centre, they believed that this undertaking will advance interfaith tolerance and regard and it will be grounds for the remainder of the universe that America base against force and intolerance. Farah Akbar stated in her article that Colleen Kelly who lost her brother on 9/11 said that “ one might presume that god the same God to Jews, Christians and Muslims would be pleased with any type of attempts that involve supplication ” . Donna o connor whose girl died in 9/11 said that “ to penalize a group of people who live in peace for the Acts of the Apostless of a few is incorrect ” . Herb Qaeda who son died in 9/11 said that “ they support edifice of this centre in lower Manhattan “ . It shows us that there are some Americans who do non link the faith to what happened that twenty-four hours in 9/11 although they have lost a member of their household.

The people who are responsible for the community centre have defended their undertaking against those who oppose it. Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf and Daisy khan proposed the thought of constructing a Muslim community centre in lower Manhattan. They said It will function as a platform for multi religion duologue, it will endeavor to advance inter community peace and tolerance and it will supply a topographic point where persons irrespective of their civilization or background will happen a topographic point of larning humanistic disciplines and civilization. Imam Feisal stated that “ this centre will supply a topographic point where persons regardless their faith or civilization will happen a topographic point of larning humanistic disciplines and civilization ” . ( Cordoba enterprise ) . Imam Feisal is a laminitis of this undertaking and he wishes to portion a vision of a community centre and society will work together to beef up community coherence and progress the shared ends of moderateness peace and apprehension.

Many politicians show their abdominal support to the undertaking including president barrack obama, city manager Michael Bloomberg, Former USA president measure Clinton and etc. Rich nurserymans reference in his article that president Barack Obama said that “ Moslems have the right to pattern their faith in the state as anyone else ” .mayor Michael Bloomberg said that “ this site was a really appropriate topographic point for edifice mosque as it tells the universe that besides has freedom of faith for everyone ” . Former us president measure Clinton besides supported park 51 and he said “ many Muslims were besides killed in 9/11 onslaughts he said that leaders of the undertaking could hold avoided this controversial issue if they related the undertaking to the Muslim victims of the onslaughts ” . Mahmoud Al portion a founding member and leader of Hamas besides supported the undertaking. He said that “ we have to construct everyplace, we have to construct this mosque as it is the lone topographic point for us as Muslims to pray ” . It has been clarified that there is something taking topographic point behind the scenes. Politicians non usual say a right word they ever want to fulfill the American people to elect them.

Some American people are against constructing this community centre. This edifice receives terrible resistance by the 9/11 households of victims, they believed that the terrorist who committed the onslaughts were Muslims, oppositions to park 51 want the undertaking to be located anyplace else as it is sensitive to the household of victims. Shadi Hamid reference in his article that see downwind hanson who lost her boy said that “ the hurting ne’er goes off when she looks over there and see a mosque ” . Evelyn Pentagon whose girl died in 9/11 said that “ its sensitive to them as it is close to the country where their victims died ” . Oppositions to park 51 continue to smear things on Moslems by associating the felons who done the onslaughts to the universe trade centre. Laura Trevelyan stated in her article that Imam Feisal said that “ what happened that twenty-four hours was terrorist act and it seems to us that it was cloaked in the pretense of Islam ” . Not merely Americans but besides Muslims are threatened by the onslaughts of extremist and their kinky position of Islam. Imam Feisal said that “ we portion and esteem the hurting and loss suffered by the household of victims ”

Roman Catholic Church opposes constructing the Islamic community centre. They reject to sell a vacant convent to the Muslims American, they thought that Muslims American society is planned to change over, they labeled the Muslim American society terrorist sympathisers. ( BBC intelligence ) . The alteration in state attitude towards Muslims. Imam Feisal said that “ the community centre will be a platform to magnify the voices of the overpowering bulk of Moslems who loved for America and gets drowned out by action of few extremists ”

Bay people are an opposing group formed by some occupants to barricade the building of the mosque. They assume that the people who are responsible for the mosque and the Islamic community centre are associated with extremist organisation that promote terrorist act, they protest in the signifier of noise. Traffic and parking job. Frank salivate reference in his article that they have collapsed with some extremist organisations who promote terrorist act. This group claims that it has raised 30 000 $ to get down a war against the Islamic community centre.It has been reported earlier this month that oppositions of the undertaking protested when a member of group handed out free back packs. Imam Feisal said that Muslims are ever near to universe trade centre, has been the imaum of a mosque 12 block from the twin towers. Americans Muslims have been peacefully populating working and idolizing in this vicinity and were affected by 9/11. He said our neighbours encouraged us to remain here and the metropolis and the community board have encouraged us.

It has been reported in the day-to-day intelligence Two tierce of New York metropolis want the Islamic centre to be moved off from universe trade centre site. One fifth of those admitted to harbouring animus towards Muslims. 33 % said they have some sort of feeling that Muslims are floating towards terrorist than American citizens. Sydney Smith stated in his article that “ anti community centre featured great Wilder the controversial anti Islamic Dutch who has called for Muslims adult females who wear headscarves should pay money for revenue enhancements and opposed the edifice of a new mosque in Netherlands ” . The choler towards the Islamic community centre has spread to many parts of the state. Police commissioner beam Kelly said that the prejudice onslaughts towards Moslems have been on the rise since 2001.about 10 offenses every twelvemonth, this twelvemonth have been already 10 instances including a Muslim who drives a auto in New York metropolis was slashed in the oral cavity and pharynx by a rider. A 37 twelvemonth old queens occupant. He was on his manner to the mosque where five work forces surrounded him and began pluging him.in Westbury, immature people threw rocks and shattering Windowss of a auto parked in forepart of Islamic centre. NY constabularies arrested five teens for upseting spiritual services at a mosque. Sheila lawn said that “ incidents such as these occurred shortly after 9/11 ” .

Those who oppose the building of the mosque has been upset by Imam Feisal and his associates policy that they insisted on go oning constructing the community centre despite the expostulation they received by the households of victims who affected by terrorist onslaughts. Some in resistance appear to be anger from the people who are responsible that they do non about expostulation and they did non even open a duologue about traveling Islamic centre and here comes the political relations function. The Islamic community centre has received resistance by many politicians. John Esposito has stated in his article that there are some people play an of import function in increasing the figure of oppositions and those people is politicians. Imam Faisal Abdul Ruth said in a recent interview with Larry king “ and it began as a consequence of some politicians who decide make benefit of the state of affairs for certain political issues ” .

Republican senator John McCain is against park 51 undertaking he said “ this undertaking would harm dealingss instead than aid ” . The former caput of democratic national commission bases against constructing the centre said “ the centre should be built anyplace else to honour those killed in ship 11 and demo sensitiveness to their households ” . Former city manager Rudolph Giuliani opposed the undertaking “ the undertaking would ache the households of those killed on Sept 11 really severely “ . Bloomberg sees the political from his point of position he said that “ this whole issue will come to an terminal during the following election otherwise something else happen takes topographic point behind the seen “ . He said during an visual aspect on the day-to-day show with John Stewart “ this is obvious that many people seeking to acquire to the top by taking an action against the community centre to acquire up promotion and celebrated every bit good as seeking to polarise people so they can acquire some ballots ” .

Cristillo believes that political relations is a major factor in this issue but he sees from his point of position that societal and economic factor play a function in this issue. He said that this is an issue is an of import mark for the authorities to illume the musca volitanss on it to do people busy with something instead than the jobs already exist because of the inability of authorities to work out the economic crisis and convey it back to its normal place before the following presidential election in 2012. The societal American organisations view mosques as an illustration of infinites that does non fit with American values and civilization. All this has no uncertainty that has pushed park 51 which is in fact a local issue into the national sphere political relations mostly Republicans but Democrats as sen harry Reid and howard dean, they both said that the centre should be built anyplace else.

Oppositions of mosques throughout New York metropolis have been controlled by the spirit to travel the mosque off from land zero site. The board of the Roman Catholic church late rejected a proposal to sell a vacant to Muslim American society which will alter it into a mosque. There are some Muslims that oppose the building of this community centre including the laminitis American Islamic forum for democracy zuhdi jasser he said “ land nothing should non be a location to advance Islam, it is the topographic point where war starts against us as Americans ” . Abdul Rahman al Rashid general director of Al Arabiya telecasting he said “ that the mosque is non a job for Muslims, they have non heard it until the protagonists and dissenters face each other, it is an statement between non Muslims in USA ” . Rima fakih the first Muslim American crowned Miss USA as Miss USA 2010 she said “ she opposed the mosque as being sensitive to the households of 9/11 victims, she agrees with the president Obama with rights of freedom faith but it should non be excessively close to land nothing ” .

There is besides a contention about support beginnings. Imam Feisal abdul rauf said that non found for this undertaking has been raised till now before funding issue get down a new organisation which is non net income will be formed. A undertaking of this graduated table will necessitate every spot of diverse support beginnings including single from all beliefs and religions, including Hebrews and Christians who are committed to peace and understanding. We expect that our beginnings of support will include persons from assorted faiths, public financess, charitable organisation, institutional and corporate patrons. He said besides “ we will ask for the New York charity organisations and the us exchequer section to reexamine our donor list to guarantee all support beginnings are vetted to their satisfaction and approved ” . In add-on to the consultative board and new non-profit-making organisations will include a multi-faith group of different person who will guarantee that the community centre remain true to its aim of peace and tolerance and apprehension between all. This community centre is opposed to spiritual extremists of all religions. American people will non be intimidated and will fall in and united together to advance peace, moderateness and apprehension. This community centre will be an of import measure towards constructing apprehension and peace.

Finally those who against the building of the Islamic community centre to be near to the universe trade centre site are upset by the manner Imam Feisal abdul rauf and his organisations are insisted to go on this undertaking despite the expostulations they received from the oppositions chiefly those households who lost their victims at land zero as a consequence of terrorist as they said. Resistance to the Islamic community centre due to Imam Feisal abdul rauf sentiments and his point of position when he said that the onslaughts on universe trade centre that takes topographic point in 9/11 were as a consequence of American foreign policy which want to do places is the first discharge of condemnable as a terrorist organisation and these I think sufficient grounds who make anyone who do non cognize anything about the issue will be demo his support to the Americans in their determination to halt constructing the Islamic community centre near land zero. On the other manus Imam Feisal abdul rauf has gained blessing from political leaders including president barrack obama to mayor Michael Bloomberg. Everyone has the right to pattern his ain faith in the united provinces and this is their regulations despite of that they break it by take a firm standing to travel the undertaking off from land zero and they do non desire to construct mosque in any topographic point in the USA.The end of Imam Feisal Abdul El roof from the oppositions point of position is to put in portion in the united provinces alternatively of civil jurisprudence. Because Imam Feisal did non state such a thing, the grounds of that he wants to construct the Islamic community centre for multi interfaith duologue and he even permit every one no affair his faith or civilization are, he can larn humanistic disciplines and civilizations through the Islamic community centre. As I said before it is non a mosque, it is an Islamic community centre and the mosque occupy the top two floors and that is the job takes topographic point because they can non understand the nature of the undertaking.

It is now clip for Americans to understand that we as Muslims Americans in this state are non responsible for the onslaughts that happened in universe trade centre in 9/11.it is non just that Americans refer to us as terrorist and do us guilty and responsible for the onslaughts although we did non cognize those people who done the onslaughts. They must halt to handle us as immigrant anymore.We are now stand foring the first, 2nd and 3rd coevals of Americans, We are portion of our society. If park 51 were understood in a right manner, it would make many chances for more than 150 occupations in lower Manhattan which has n’t returned to its normal place economically since 2001.this undertaking plays an of import function that Americans must be realized. It will make many chances for employment and will convey people to the country and will assist to retrieve lower Manhattan economically. I support park 51 and I hope to go a topographic point of inspiration for everyone to happen peace and apprehension.

Work cited

Ahmed, Leila. “ Improving Muslin West Relations ” . CORDBA INTIATIVE. 17.OCT.2010 & lt ; www.cordobaintiative.org.html & gt ; .

Akbar, Farah. “ Civil Rights. “ GOTHAMGAZETTE.Sep 2009.7 Oct 2010.

& lt ; www.gothamgazette.com /article/civilrights.html & gt ; .

Esposito, John. “ Safe Guarding Muslim-west dealingss. ” WEEKLY.AHRAM. 17 Oct 2010. & lt ; www.weekly.ahram.org.eg/2010/1015/op112.html & gt ; .

Gardner, rich. “ theCordoba House Proposal ” . PHILLYIMC. 18.AUG.2010.27.OCT.2010 & lt ; www.phillyimc.org.html & gt ; .

Hamid, shadiness. “ Will traveling park 51 mosque ” . DEMOCRACY ARSENAL. 23.Aug.2010.17.oct.2010 & lt ; www.democracyarsenal.org.html & gt ; .

Lalwani, Sheila. “ There may be a community centre ” . WEEKLY AHRAM. 17.OCT.2010 & lt ; www.weekly.ahram.org.html & gt ; .

Rothman, moral. “ Why I Support Park 51 Community Center. ” NEWVOICES. 27 Sep.2010.7 Oct.2010. & lt ; www.blog.new voices.org/ ? p=4387.html & gt ; .

Salvato, Frank.. ” The Consequence of Park 51. ” AIM.6 Aug 2010.7 Oct 2010.

& lt ; www.aim.org/guest-column/the-consequence-of-park51.html & gt ; .

Sydney, Smith. “ There Is No Land Zero Mosque ” . STINKY JOURNALISM. 4.sep.2010.17.oct.2010 & lt ; www.stinkyjournalism.org.html & gt ; .

Trevelyan, Laura. “ Muslim Developer Defends NY Ground Zero Plan ” .BBC.

29.Sep.2010.27.Oct.2010 & lt ; www.bbc.co.uk.html & gt ; .